[Cz-physics] I would appreciate a critique of the article "Compressibility factor (gases)"

Alexander E. Patrakov patrakov at gmail.com
Thu Apr 3 03:58:42 CDT 2008


2008/4/3, mbeychok <mbeychok at cox.net>:
>
>  Hello all:
>
>  I just created the article "Compressibility factor (gases)" and installed
> it in Citizendium. If any of you are knowledgeable of that subject, I would
> very much appreciate a critique of the article given either here by email or
> on the Talk page of the article.

It is not immediately clear whether Figure 2 is an averaged
experimental plot or a theoretical plot according to some model. If it
is experimental, it would be nice to also include a plot according to
the van der Waals equation (because you have some experimental plots
and a model formula with no way to compare the two directly).

More on Figure 2: it doesn't include regions where Z > 1, while Figure
1 does. Why the discrepancy?

-- 
Alexander E. Patrakov
P.S. I am more qualified to talk about semiconductors, not gases, so
please take the above as general suggestions from a non-specialist


More information about the Cz-physics mailing list