CZ:Proposals/A new subpage for translations of approved articles: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Stephen Ewen
(Permission to translate articles is already granted under terms of the CC-by-sa-3.0.)
imported>Jens Mildner
(First draft)
Line 1: Line 1:
['''Note to the proposer:''' please delete these lines after reading!  Please bear in mind that if you do not volunteer to be the driver of the proposal, and you do not fill it out in great detail, then your proposal or issue will be addressed ''only if'' a driver is found.  So, if you really do want your work not to go to waste, please do help locate a driver for your proposal.  Thanks!  Now please delete the foregoing message!]
{{proposal assignment}}
{{proposal assignment}}


Line 6: Line 4:


== Complete explanation ==
== Complete explanation ==
''A complete, clear, feasible, and (as applicable) step-by-step explanation of the proposal. Or, if an issue: a complete and fair explanation of the competing positions that the decisionmakers are being asked to consider.''
This proposal aims for the CZ community to officially endorse translations of approved articles and to encourage people to start such translations under given circumstances that will be subject to discussion.
 
Once a positive decision has been made there shall be a new default subpage type "Translations" for approved articles where links to different translations will be collected.
 
example link: German / deutsch: Biologie
 
The actual naming convention for the translated article itself could be Article/Translations/Language.
 
example: Biology/Translations/German
 
 
Furthermore, an Eduzendium initiative could be started for language scholars to translate long and complex articles as a course project.


== Reasoning ==
== Reasoning ==
''The reasoning behind the proposal, or behind the various options offered in the issue.  Make sure it is clear what problem you're trying to solve (or opportunity you're trying to leverage), and the proposal would solve the problem.''
I think it is perfectly clear that CZ aims to be a mature and better Wikipedia in the not too far future. This implies CZ projects in other languages than English. Having said that, the proposal above shall be seen as an easy-to-implement and very convenient preparation for the start of the first international CZ.


== Implementation ==
== Implementation ==

Revision as of 09:23, 24 February 2008

This proposal has not yet been assigned to any decisionmaking group or decisionmaker(s).
The Proposals Manager will do so soon if and when the proposal or issue is "well formed" (including having a driver).
For now, the proposal record can be found in the new proposals queue.


Driver: (please specify, if any)

Complete explanation

This proposal aims for the CZ community to officially endorse translations of approved articles and to encourage people to start such translations under given circumstances that will be subject to discussion.

Once a positive decision has been made there shall be a new default subpage type "Translations" for approved articles where links to different translations will be collected.

example link: German / deutsch: Biologie

The actual naming convention for the translated article itself could be Article/Translations/Language.

example: Biology/Translations/German


Furthermore, an Eduzendium initiative could be started for language scholars to translate long and complex articles as a course project.

Reasoning

I think it is perfectly clear that CZ aims to be a mature and better Wikipedia in the not too far future. This implies CZ projects in other languages than English. Having said that, the proposal above shall be seen as an easy-to-implement and very convenient preparation for the start of the first international CZ.

Implementation

A practical "to do list" type explanation of how the proposal will be implemented, and who will implement it. If there is no one to implement the proposal (as, for example, with many technical or recruitment proposals), then it is automatically declined.

Discussion

A discussion section, to which anyone may contribute.

Allowing translations seems harmless as long as there's a disclaimer indicating that errors may have been introduced during translation, so why not? However, I don't think we should go so far as to actively encourage this currently. Warren Schudy 12:55, 23 February 2008 (CST)

Permission to translate articles is already granted under terms of the CC-by-sa-3.0. Stephen Ewen 14:12, 23 February 2008 (CST)

Proposals System Navigation (advanced users only)

Proposal lists (some planned pages are still blank):