User:Daniel Mietchen/Talks/COASP 2010/Wikis as platforms for OA publishing: Difference between revisions
< User:Daniel Mietchen | Talks | COASP 2010
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
imported>Daniel Mietchen |
imported>Daniel Mietchen m (update) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{:User/Daniel_Mietchen/COASP2010/Template}} | {{:User/Daniel_Mietchen/COASP2010/Template}} | ||
*The idea is not new — [http://meatballwiki.org/wiki/WikiSciencePublication WikiSciencePublication] stated in 2006: | |||
:"Somewhere at the fringe of science, someone will start using wiki publishing for science publishing." | |||
== Wikis as platforms for science communication in general == | == Wikis as platforms for science communication in general == | ||
| Line 11: | Line 14: | ||
== Wikis as platforms for OA publishing == | == Wikis as platforms for OA publishing == | ||
*Open Access by [http://eoearth.org/article/EoE_FAQs#Can_I_use_material_published_in_the_EoE.3F default] (non-open licenses are [http://www.scholarpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Copyright&id=1 possible]) | *Open Access by [http://eoearth.org/article/EoE_FAQs#Can_I_use_material_published_in_the_EoE.3F default] (non-open licenses are [http://www.scholarpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Copyright&id=1 possible]) | ||
**Fine-grained configurability of [[User:Chris Key/Sandbox/Proposal: Overhaul of user rights#Summary of Rights Given to Each User Group|user rights]], thereby allowing for any peer review model (and any business model). | |||
* | |||
*[http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Wikis_in_scholarly_communication#Comparison_between_paper-based_and_wiki-based_scholarly_communication_systems In comparison to paper-based scholarly communication]: | *[http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Wikis_in_scholarly_communication#Comparison_between_paper-based_and_wiki-based_scholarly_communication_systems In comparison to paper-based scholarly communication]: | ||
**Web-native: Basically anything on the web can be [http://test.citizendium.org/wiki/CZ:Widget_tests#Widget:SlideShare embedded] or otherwise directly linked to | **Web-native: Basically anything on the web can be [http://test.citizendium.org/wiki/CZ:Widget_tests#Widget:SlideShare embedded] or otherwise directly linked to | ||
| Line 19: | Line 20: | ||
**[http://en.citizendium.org/wiki?title=User:Daniel_Mietchen/Talks/COASP_2010/Overview&action=history Version control] built in (along with time stamps, naturally), thus allowing [[NMR_spectroscopy|stable releases]] ''and'' [[NMR_spectroscopy/Draft|updatability]], while establishing priority | **[http://en.citizendium.org/wiki?title=User:Daniel_Mietchen/Talks/COASP_2010/Overview&action=history Version control] built in (along with time stamps, naturally), thus allowing [[NMR_spectroscopy|stable releases]] ''and'' [[NMR_spectroscopy/Draft|updatability]], while establishing priority | ||
*Several [http://www.wikimatrix.org/compare/3F-Wiki%2B%40Wiki%2BAnwiki%2Bbitweaver%2BbLADE-Wiki%2BBoltWire%2BBrainKeeper%2BBusinessWiki%2BButorWiki%2BCanvasWiki%2BCentralDesktop%2BClearspace%2BClearWiki%2BcodeBeamer%2BConfluence%2BConnectedText%2BCorendal-Wiki%2BCospire%2BDaisy%2BDokuWiki%2BDrupal-Wiki%2BEditMe%2BErfurtWiki%2BFlexWiki%2BFoswiki%2BFriki%2BGazest%2BGeboGebo%2BGeniusWiki%2BGiki%2BGit-Wiki%2Bgitit%2BGroupswiki%2BHatta%2BIkeWiki%2Bikiwiki%2BIncentive%2BInstiki%2BIntodit%2BJacwiki%2BJAMWiki%2BJaWiki%2BJSPWiki%2BKeheiWiki%2BLionWiki%2BLuminotes%2BLunaWiki%2BMediaWiki%2BMetadot-Wiki%2BMidgard-Wiki%2BMindTouch%2BminiWiki%2BMoinMoin%2BMojoMojo%2BMoniWiki%2BNetcipia%2Bnexdo%2BOddmuse%2BOpenWikiNG%2BPageWork%2BPAUX%2BPBwiki%2BPhpWiki%2BPimki%2BPmWiki%2BPodWiki%2BProjectForum%2BProntoWiki%2BProWiki%2BPukiWiki%2BRiki%2BSamePage%2BScrewTurn-Wiki%2BSharePoint-Wiki-Plus%2BSocialtext%2BSpringnote%2BSputnik%2BSubWiki%2BSwirrl%2BSycamore%2Btelepark.wiki%2BThoughtFarmer%2BTiddlyWiki%2BTiki-Wiki-CMS-Groupware%2BTraction-TeamPage%2BTracWiki%2BTriki-Wiki%2BTWiki%2BUniWakka%2BUseMod%2BVQWiki%2BWackoWiki%2BWagn%2BWala-Wiki%2BWetpaint%2BWicked%2BWiclear%2BWiGit%2BWiki-Spot%2BWiki-Toolkit%2BWikia%2BWikiASP%2BWikiCrowd%2BWikiDoc%2BWikidot%2BWikiNi%2BWikiSH%2BWikispaces%2BWikkaWiki%2BWikyBlog%2BwxWikiServer%2BXoWiki%2BXWiki%2Byawiki%2BZoho-Wiki%2BZwiki popular wikis] are open source and have been tested under high load | *Several [http://www.wikimatrix.org/compare/3F-Wiki%2B%40Wiki%2BAnwiki%2Bbitweaver%2BbLADE-Wiki%2BBoltWire%2BBrainKeeper%2BBusinessWiki%2BButorWiki%2BCanvasWiki%2BCentralDesktop%2BClearspace%2BClearWiki%2BcodeBeamer%2BConfluence%2BConnectedText%2BCorendal-Wiki%2BCospire%2BDaisy%2BDokuWiki%2BDrupal-Wiki%2BEditMe%2BErfurtWiki%2BFlexWiki%2BFoswiki%2BFriki%2BGazest%2BGeboGebo%2BGeniusWiki%2BGiki%2BGit-Wiki%2Bgitit%2BGroupswiki%2BHatta%2BIkeWiki%2Bikiwiki%2BIncentive%2BInstiki%2BIntodit%2BJacwiki%2BJAMWiki%2BJaWiki%2BJSPWiki%2BKeheiWiki%2BLionWiki%2BLuminotes%2BLunaWiki%2BMediaWiki%2BMetadot-Wiki%2BMidgard-Wiki%2BMindTouch%2BminiWiki%2BMoinMoin%2BMojoMojo%2BMoniWiki%2BNetcipia%2Bnexdo%2BOddmuse%2BOpenWikiNG%2BPageWork%2BPAUX%2BPBwiki%2BPhpWiki%2BPimki%2BPmWiki%2BPodWiki%2BProjectForum%2BProntoWiki%2BProWiki%2BPukiWiki%2BRiki%2BSamePage%2BScrewTurn-Wiki%2BSharePoint-Wiki-Plus%2BSocialtext%2BSpringnote%2BSputnik%2BSubWiki%2BSwirrl%2BSycamore%2Btelepark.wiki%2BThoughtFarmer%2BTiddlyWiki%2BTiki-Wiki-CMS-Groupware%2BTraction-TeamPage%2BTracWiki%2BTriki-Wiki%2BTWiki%2BUniWakka%2BUseMod%2BVQWiki%2BWackoWiki%2BWagn%2BWala-Wiki%2BWetpaint%2BWicked%2BWiclear%2BWiGit%2BWiki-Spot%2BWiki-Toolkit%2BWikia%2BWikiASP%2BWikiCrowd%2BWikiDoc%2BWikidot%2BWikiNi%2BWikiSH%2BWikispaces%2BWikkaWiki%2BWikyBlog%2BwxWikiServer%2BXoWiki%2BXWiki%2Byawiki%2BZoho-Wiki%2BZwiki popular wikis] are open source and have been tested under high load | ||
*The more open research becomes, the [http://ways.org/files/Open_Science_Adapting_the_research_cycle_animated-small.gif more diverse] will the acts of science publishing become. Wikis exist for [[User:Daniel Mietchen/Talks/LSWT 2010/Integrating wikis with scientific workflows|all aspects of the research cycle]] (except for funding decisions, | |||
*built-in [[article-level metrics]] at bottom of page and via [[Special:WhatLinksHere|What links here]] (which could also be used for other pages, e.g. those hosting images, references, or datasets), author-level metrics via [[Special:Contributions/Daniel_Mietchen|Special:Contributions]], further aggregation possible (e.g. at the level of [http://openwetware.org/wiki/User:Carl_Boettiger/Notebook/Stochastic_Population_Dynamics#Collected_Literature research projects], [http://usefulchem.wikispaces.com/ labs] or [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki?title=Special:RecentChangesLinked&target=Category%3ABiology_tag thematic workgroups]) | |||
*The more open research becomes, the [http://ways.org/files/Open_Science_Adapting_the_research_cycle_animated-small.gif more diverse] will the acts of science publishing become. Wikis exist for [[User:Daniel Mietchen/Talks/LSWT 2010/Integrating wikis with scientific workflows|all aspects of the research cycle]] (except for funding decisions, though the reasons are not of a technical nature) | |||
Revision as of 18:08, 20 August 2010
The account of this former contributor was not re-activated after the server upgrade of March 2022.
Wikis as platforms for Open Access publishing · Prototypes · Editorial policies · Guided tour ·
Obstacles · Alternatives · Outlook · Summary · Slides · Video · Q & A · Demo
- The idea is not new — WikiSciencePublication stated in 2006:
- "Somewhere at the fringe of science, someone will start using wiki publishing for science publishing."
Wikis as platforms for science communication in general
- Wikis can be used, in principle, for any aspect of scholarly communication, as detailed in this comparison of wiki- and paper-based communication systems and the related blog post.
- Examples exist for all steps of the research cycle, except successful applications to major funders (see this overview for some attempts)
- Benchmark: English Wikipedia
Wikis as platforms for OA publishing
- Open Access by default (non-open licenses are possible)
- Fine-grained configurability of user rights, thereby allowing for any peer review model (and any business model).
- In comparison to paper-based scholarly communication:
- Web-native: Basically anything on the web can be embedded or otherwise directly linked to
- Contextual links are the central pillar
- Version control built in (along with time stamps, naturally), thus allowing stable releases and updatability, while establishing priority
- Several popular wikis are open source and have been tested under high load
- built-in article-level metrics at bottom of page and via What links here (which could also be used for other pages, e.g. those hosting images, references, or datasets), author-level metrics via Special:Contributions, further aggregation possible (e.g. at the level of research projects, labs or thematic workgroups)
- The more open research becomes, the more diverse will the acts of science publishing become. Wikis exist for all aspects of the research cycle (except for funding decisions, though the reasons are not of a technical nature)
