Truong Chinh: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
m (Text replacement - "Vo Nguyen Giap" to "Vo Nguyen Giap")
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
{{TOC-right}}
{{TOC|right}}
'''Truong Chinh''' (1907-1988) was one of the founders of the Indochinese Communist Party, with more of a focus on principally political [[dau trinh|''dau trinh'' struggle]] than the more armed struggle of his internal rival, [[Vo Nguyen Giap]]. At various times, he was demoted, but later came back as a more powerful ideologist, in and out of the highest circles. Both he and Giap, however, were basically pro-Soviet, while their later rival, [[Le Duan]], was more Chinese-oriented. His Soviet sympathies, however, were more Stalinist, not reflecting [[Nikita Khrushchev]]'s caution at keeping wars of national liberation differentiated from wars between nation-states. <ref name=Palmer>{{citation
'''Truong Chinh''' (1907-1988) was one of the founders of the [[Indochinese Communist Party]], with more of a focus on principally political [[dau tranh|''dau tranh'' (struggle)]] than the more armed struggle of his internal rival, Vo Nguyen Giap. At various times, he was demoted, but later came back as a more powerful ideologist, in and out of the highest circles. Both he and Giap, however, were basically pro-Soviet, while their later rival, [[Le Duan]], was more Chinese-oriented. His Soviet sympathies, however, were more Stalinist, not reflecting [[Nikita Khrushchev]]'s caution at keeping wars of national liberation differentiated from wars between nation-states. <ref name=Palmer>{{citation
  | first = Dave R. | last = Palmer
  | first = Dave R. | last = Palmer
  | title = Summons of the Trumpet | publisher = Presidio Press | year = 1978}}, p. 63</ref>
  | title = Summons of the Trumpet | publisher = Presidio Press | year = 1978}}, p. 63</ref>  


Born as Dang Xuan Khu, he was an early revolutionary, jailed by the French from 1930 to 1936. Truong Chinh means "Long March"; it was his revolutionary alias but he changed his name to it in honor of [[Mao Tse Tung]], perhaps another indication of his political rather than military bent. <ref name=NYT1988-10-02>{{citation
Born as Dang Xuan Khu, he was an early revolutionary, jailed by the French from 1930 to 1936. Truong Chinh means "Long March"; it was his revolutionary alias but he changed his name to it in honor of [[Mao Zedong]], perhaps another indication of his political rather than military bent. <ref name=NYT1988-10-02>{{citation
  | title = Truong Chinh Dies in Hanoi at 80; Was in Ho Chi Minh's Inner Circle  
  | title = Truong Chinh Dies in Hanoi at 80; Was in Ho Chi Minh's Inner Circle  
  | first = Glenn | last = Fowler | date =  October 2, 1988 | journal = New York Times
  | first = Glenn | last = Fowler | date =  October 2, 1988 | journal = New York Times
  | url = http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE4DA1738F931A35753C1A96E948260&sec=&spon=}}</ref>
  | url = http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE4DA1738F931A35753C1A96E948260&sec=&spon=}}</ref>


Going to China with Ho and Giap, he returned in 1946, and was chief of propaganda and ideology, ranking only behind Ho in the Party.<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 /> Giap's victory at [[Dien Bien Phu]] weakened him. From 1951 to 1956, he was secretary general of the Vietnam Workers Party, but dismissed over land reform. <ref name=Patti>{{cite book
Going to China with Ho and Giap, he returned in 1946, and was chief of propaganda and ideology, ranking only behind Ho in the Party.<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 /> Giap's victory at [[Dien Bien Phu]] weakened him. From 1951 to 1956, he was secretary general of the [[Vietnam Workers Party]], but dismissed over land reform. <ref name=Patti>{{cite book
  | title = Why Viet Nam? Prelude to America's Albatross  
  | title = Why Viet Nam? Prelude to America's Albatross  
  | author = Patti, Archimedes L. A.
  | author = Patti, Archimedes L. A.
Line 19: Line 19:


==Land reform==
==Land reform==
After 1954, he created People's Agricultural Reform Tribunals, which were especially harsh on Catholic landholders that had not gone to the South. There were purges and an eventual insurrection in Ho's home province of Nghe Anh. The number of deaths is not known: 50,000 have been mentioned,<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 /> but Sheehan dismisses that as [[Central Intelligence Agency]] propaganda, although he agrees the deaths were in the thousands. Ho apologized in 1956, dismissed Chinh from his ministry (but retained him in the Politburo),<ref name=Karnow>{{citation
After 1954, he created People's Agricultural Reform Tribunals, which were especially harsh on Catholic landholders that had not gone to the South. There were purges and an eventual insurrection in Ho's home province of [[Quang Ngai]]. The number of deaths is not known: 50,000 have been mentioned,<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 /> but Sheehan dismisses that as [[Central Intelligence Agency]] propaganda, although he agrees the deaths were in the thousands. Ho apologized in 1956, dismissed Chinh from his ministry (but retained him in the Politburo),<ref name=Karnow>{{citation
  | first = Stanley | last = Karnow
  | first = Stanley | last = Karnow
  | title = Vietnam, a History
  | title = Vietnam, a History
Line 32: Line 32:
  | url = http://www.vietnam.ttu.edu/star/images/239/2390414002A.pdf
  | url = http://www.vietnam.ttu.edu/star/images/239/2390414002A.pdf
  | comment = second URL = http://www.vietnam.ttu.edu/star/images/239/2390414002B.pdf
  | comment = second URL = http://www.vietnam.ttu.edu/star/images/239/2390414002B.pdf
}}</ref> Gradually, he was  rehabilitated into the  the National Assembly in 1960. He opposed combat against U.S. ground troops, counseling [[dau trinh|political ''dau trinh'':]] organization and guerilla warfare.  
}}</ref> Gradually, he was  rehabilitated into the  the National Assembly in 1960. He opposed combat against U.S. ground troops, counseling [[dau tranh|political ''dau tranh'':]] organization and [[guerrilla warfare]].
 
==Changing strategy toward the South==
==Changing strategy toward the South==
Still, he is associated with a December 1963 Politburo decision to change the general direction of strategy to the [[General Offensive-General Uprising]]. It recast the conflict as less the classic, protracted war of Maoist doctrine, and the destabilization of doctrine under Khruschev, than a decision that it was possible to accelerate. "on the one hand we must thoroughly understand the guideline for a protracted struggle, but on the other hand we must seize the opportunities to win victories in a not too long a period of time...There is no contradiction in the concept of a protracted war and the concept of taking opportunities to gain victories in a short time."<ref>Palmer, p. 63</ref>.
Still, he is associated with a December 1963 Politburo decision to change the general direction of strategy to the [[General Offensive-General Uprising]]. It recast the conflict as less the classic, protracted war of Maoist doctrine, and the destabilization of doctrine under Khrushchev, than a decision that it was possible to accelerate. "on the one hand we must thoroughly understand the guideline for a protracted struggle, but on the other hand we must seize the opportunities to win victories in a not too long a period of time...There is no contradiction in the concept of a protracted war and the concept of taking opportunities to gain victories in a short time."<ref>Palmer, p. 63</ref>.


==After the failure of the TKC/TCN==
==After the failure of the General Offensive-General Uprising==
After the setbacks of late 1967 and 1968, [[Le Duan]], weaker in political theory and more hard-line on military action,  surpassed him 1969, becoming General Secretary.  
After the setbacks of late 1967 and 1968, [[Le Duan]], weaker in political theory and more hard-line on military action,  surpassed him 1969, becoming General Secretary.  


Le Duan, who had not been known to write extensively, published a theoretical article in the party newspaper, Nhan Dan, on February 14, 1970, establishing the dominance of his line and making him more likely to succeed Ho.<ref name=RFE>{{citation  
Le Duan, who had not been known to write extensively, published a theoretical article in the party newspaper, ''[[Nhan Dan]]'', on February 14, 1970, establishing the dominance of his line and making him more likely to succeed Ho.<ref name=RFE>{{citation  
  | author = Radio Free Europe research staff
  | author = Radio Free Europe research staff
  | date = 25 February 1970
  | date = 25 February 1970
  | title = Le Duan's Theoretical Treatise and the Problem of Succession in Hanoi
  | title = Le Duan's Theoretical Treatise and the Problem of Succession in Hanoi
  | url = http://www.osa.ceu.hu/files/holdings/300/8/3/text/38-1-197.shtml}}</ref>  Nevertheless, in 1979, Truong Chinh regained Politburo sttus.
  | url = http://www.osa.ceu.hu/files/holdings/300/8/3/text/38-1-197.shtml}}</ref>  Nevertheless, in 1979, Truong Chinh regained Politburo status.


In 1982, he headed a mission to Moscow, unsuccessfully requesting for Soviet economic assistance.<ref>Karnow, p. 32</ref> He served as General Secretary for six months in 1986, but was retired over loss of confidence in economic leadership, being replaced by [[Nguyen Van Linh]], a market-oriented Communist whom Truong Chinh had purged in 1982.
In 1982, he headed a mission to Moscow, unsuccessfully requesting for Soviet economic assistance.<ref>Karnow, p. 32</ref> He served as General Secretary for six months in 1986, but was retired over loss of confidence in economic leadership, being replaced by [[Nguyen Van Linh]], a market-oriented Communist whom Truong Chinh had purged in 1982.


After Ho's death in 1988, only three of Ho's closest associates remained:<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 />  [[Pham van Dong]], [[Le Duc Tho]] and [[Vo Nguyen Giap]], probably Truong Chinh's greatest rival.
After Ho's death in 1988, only three of Ho's closest associates remained:<ref name=NYT1988-10-02 />  [[Pham van Dong]], [[Le Duc Tho]] and Vo Nguyen Giap, probably Truong Chinh's greatest rival.


==References==
==References==
{{reflist|2}}
{{reflist|2}}
[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]

Latest revision as of 09:19, 3 December 2024

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Truong Chinh (1907-1988) was one of the founders of the Indochinese Communist Party, with more of a focus on principally political dau tranh (struggle) than the more armed struggle of his internal rival, Vo Nguyen Giap. At various times, he was demoted, but later came back as a more powerful ideologist, in and out of the highest circles. Both he and Giap, however, were basically pro-Soviet, while their later rival, Le Duan, was more Chinese-oriented. His Soviet sympathies, however, were more Stalinist, not reflecting Nikita Khrushchev's caution at keeping wars of national liberation differentiated from wars between nation-states. [1]

Born as Dang Xuan Khu, he was an early revolutionary, jailed by the French from 1930 to 1936. Truong Chinh means "Long March"; it was his revolutionary alias but he changed his name to it in honor of Mao Zedong, perhaps another indication of his political rather than military bent. [2]

Going to China with Ho and Giap, he returned in 1946, and was chief of propaganda and ideology, ranking only behind Ho in the Party.[2] Giap's victory at Dien Bien Phu weakened him. From 1951 to 1956, he was secretary general of the Vietnam Workers Party, but dismissed over land reform. [3]

Land reform

After 1954, he created People's Agricultural Reform Tribunals, which were especially harsh on Catholic landholders that had not gone to the South. There were purges and an eventual insurrection in Ho's home province of Quang Ngai. The number of deaths is not known: 50,000 have been mentioned,[2] but Sheehan dismisses that as Central Intelligence Agency propaganda, although he agrees the deaths were in the thousands. Ho apologized in 1956, dismissed Chinh from his ministry (but retained him in the Politburo),[4] and Giap made a speech to a Central Committee meeting, saying there were unjust executions and terror. [5]

Rehabilitation

He published a theoretical book in 1958. [6] Gradually, he was rehabilitated into the the National Assembly in 1960. He opposed combat against U.S. ground troops, counseling political dau tranh: organization and guerrilla warfare.

Changing strategy toward the South

Still, he is associated with a December 1963 Politburo decision to change the general direction of strategy to the General Offensive-General Uprising. It recast the conflict as less the classic, protracted war of Maoist doctrine, and the destabilization of doctrine under Khrushchev, than a decision that it was possible to accelerate. "on the one hand we must thoroughly understand the guideline for a protracted struggle, but on the other hand we must seize the opportunities to win victories in a not too long a period of time...There is no contradiction in the concept of a protracted war and the concept of taking opportunities to gain victories in a short time."[7].

After the failure of the General Offensive-General Uprising

After the setbacks of late 1967 and 1968, Le Duan, weaker in political theory and more hard-line on military action, surpassed him 1969, becoming General Secretary.

Le Duan, who had not been known to write extensively, published a theoretical article in the party newspaper, Nhan Dan, on February 14, 1970, establishing the dominance of his line and making him more likely to succeed Ho.[8] Nevertheless, in 1979, Truong Chinh regained Politburo status.

In 1982, he headed a mission to Moscow, unsuccessfully requesting for Soviet economic assistance.[9] He served as General Secretary for six months in 1986, but was retired over loss of confidence in economic leadership, being replaced by Nguyen Van Linh, a market-oriented Communist whom Truong Chinh had purged in 1982.

After Ho's death in 1988, only three of Ho's closest associates remained:[2] Pham van Dong, Le Duc Tho and Vo Nguyen Giap, probably Truong Chinh's greatest rival.

References

  1. Palmer, Dave R. (1978), Summons of the Trumpet, Presidio Press, p. 63
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Fowler, Glenn (October 2, 1988), "Truong Chinh Dies in Hanoi at 80; Was in Ho Chi Minh's Inner Circle", New York Times
  3. Patti, Archimedes L. A. (1980). Why Viet Nam? Prelude to America's Albatross. University of California Press. , pp. 479-480
  4. Karnow, Stanley (1983), Vietnam, a History, Viking Press, p. 226
  5. Sheehan, Neil. (1988), A bright shining lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam, New Random House, p. 173
  6. Truong Chinh (1958), The August Revolution, Foreign Languages Publishing House
  7. Palmer, p. 63
  8. Radio Free Europe research staff (25 February 1970), Le Duan's Theoretical Treatise and the Problem of Succession in Hanoi
  9. Karnow, p. 32