Talk:Extrajudicial detention: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Text replacement - "torture" to "torture")
m (Text replacement - "universal jurisdiction" to "universal jurisdiction")
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
== Fresh start ==
== Fresh start ==


The article page now has completely new content, obviating the Wikipedia reference. It discusses international law to the extent practical as a start; the article can't be based on [[common law]] or Anglo-US practices alone. International law is emerging here; see, for example, ''[[hostis humani generis]]'', [[universal jurisdiction]], [[extraordinary rendition]], and [[international extradition]], along with [[Geneva Conventions]] and [[Third Geneva Convention]].
The article page now has completely new content, obviating the Wikipedia reference. It discusses international law to the extent practical as a start; the article can't be based on [[common law]] or Anglo-US practices alone. International law is emerging here; see, for example, ''[[hostis humani generis]]'', universal jurisdiction, [[extraordinary rendition]], and [[international extradition]], along with [[Geneva Conventions]] and [[Third Geneva Convention]].


Structurally, this is intended to be a top-level article dealing with an internationalized view. I propose that there be articles dealing with the national practices of countries where this is a substantial issue, with appropriate subarticles. For example, in my sandbox now are [[User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUS]] dealing with general U.S. extrajudicial detention, but, due to sheer volume, there is also (more ready for mainspace) [[User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUSGWB]] dealing with 2001 onwards. Certainly, there is enough material for national articles and subarticles for many countries. Hopefully, Citizens from the British Isles will deal with everything from [[The Troubles]] to the Palestinian mandate.  
Structurally, this is intended to be a top-level article dealing with an internationalized view. I propose that there be articles dealing with the national practices of countries where this is a substantial issue, with appropriate subarticles. For example, in my sandbox now are [[User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUS]] dealing with general U.S. extrajudicial detention, but, due to sheer volume, there is also (more ready for mainspace) [[User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUSGWB]] dealing with 2001 onwards. Certainly, there is enough material for national articles and subarticles for many countries. Hopefully, Citizens from the British Isles will deal with everything from [[The Troubles]] to the Palestinian mandate.  
Line 12: Line 12:
:Many of the subarticles now exist, no longer in my sandbox:
:Many of the subarticles now exist, no longer in my sandbox:
:*[[Extrajudicial detention, U.S.]]
:*[[Extrajudicial detention, U.S.]]
:**[[Extrajudicial detention, U.S., George W. Bush Administration]]
:**Extrajudicial detention, U.S., George W. Bush Administration
:*[[Intelligence interrogation, U.S.]]
:*[[Intelligence interrogation, U.S.]]
:**Intelligence interrogation]]
:**Intelligence interrogation]]

Latest revision as of 11:51, 29 May 2024

This article is developed but not approved.
 Main Article
 Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
To learn how to update the categories for this article, see here. To update categories, edit the metadata template.
 Definition:  The policy and practice of holding prisoners captive without judicial authority to do so, or without a recognized authority under international law, such capture of prisoners of war [d] [e]
Checklist and Archives
 Workgroup categories:  Politics, Military and Law [Categories OK]
 Talk Archive:  none  English language variant:  American English


Fresh start

The article page now has completely new content, obviating the Wikipedia reference. It discusses international law to the extent practical as a start; the article can't be based on common law or Anglo-US practices alone. International law is emerging here; see, for example, hostis humani generis, universal jurisdiction, extraordinary rendition, and international extradition, along with Geneva Conventions and Third Geneva Convention.

Structurally, this is intended to be a top-level article dealing with an internationalized view. I propose that there be articles dealing with the national practices of countries where this is a substantial issue, with appropriate subarticles. For example, in my sandbox now are User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUS dealing with general U.S. extrajudicial detention, but, due to sheer volume, there is also (more ready for mainspace) User: Howard C. Berkowitz/EJUSGWB dealing with 2001 onwards. Certainly, there is enough material for national articles and subarticles for many countries. Hopefully, Citizens from the British Isles will deal with everything from The Troubles to the Palestinian mandate.

Note also that there are complementary articles on interrogation, a subset of eduction, and again with a need for national articles and subarticles (e.g., in progress User: Howard C. Berkowitz/IntUS and User: Howard C. Berkowitz/IntUSGWB. I hope these will move to mainspace soon. See also the rewritten torture. Howard C. Berkowitz 19:28, 11 March 2009 (UTC)

Many of the subarticles now exist, no longer in my sandbox:

Howard C. Berkowitz 20:08, 26 April 2009 (UTC)

Approval as top-level article?

With the very clear understanding, as shown in Related Articles, that this is a top-level article, should it be considered for Approval? Howard C. Berkowitz 20:06, 26 April 2009 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=Talk:Extrajudicial_detention&oldid=956654"