Martial arts: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Michael J. Formica
No edit summary
imported>Michael J. Formica
Line 15: Line 15:


There is much debate in the martial arts community over what the "true goal" of martial arts is or should be or if there is even such a thing.
There is much debate in the martial arts community over what the "true goal" of martial arts is or should be or if there is even such a thing.
===Striking and Grappling===
Arts focusing on unarmed and melee weapon combat are typically focused on either striking or grappling. While often there is some form of striking in grappling-focused arts and vice versa, there are also some arts that attempt to divide training somewhat evenly.
*striking - boxing, karate, kickboxing, Muay Thai, tae kwon do
*grappling - judo, aikido, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, wrestling
===Range===
Range, sometimes called the phases of combat, in this context generally refers to the distance between two fighters during a fight, although sometimes the term is interchanged with scope as defined above. Different martial arts and different contexts offer different ranges that a fight can occur at, and different martial arts concentrate in fighting in certain ranges. There is disagreement as to the number and existence of certain ranges: while certainly the physical distance can be measured, the practical distinctions between ranges are important and distinct to varying views of the theoretical division of a fight.
[[Jeet Kune Do]], the martial arts system/philosophy developed by [[Bruce Lee]], describes four ranges:
*[[kicking]]
*[[punching]]
*[[trapping]]
*[[grappling]]
The three ranges accepted in the mixed martial arts community for mixed martial arts fights (and often all unarmed fights) are:
*[[stand-up]]
*[[clinch]]
*[[ground]]
===Hard vs. Soft===
Some martial arts have made a distinction between "hard" and "soft" arts, or "external" and "internal" arts, with the distinction often being offered as a spectrum on which all arts fall. Many so-called "traditional martial arts", particularly those originating in China, accept such categorization at least in passing.
The mixed martial arts community generally forgoes this method of categorization is often ignored as being inapplicable or even inaccurate of fighting.


===Region===
===Region===

Revision as of 18:07, 8 November 2007

This article is a stub and thus not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Martial arts are codified systems of both armed and weaponless, or empty-handed,1 skills intended to develop and increase proficiency in combat. Martial arts have arisen in nearly all cultures, both through cultural transmission and independently, with some form of codified martial art, either historic or current, identifiable in virtually every culture around the world today. The scope of the martial arts is vast, and, in some sense, defies a complete categorization. Despite the universality of offensive and defensive combat techiniques when discussing martial arts it is typically in reference to the Eastern forms of combat training, which is the focus of this article.

History

Origins

It is not possible to categorical define the point of origin for the development of martial arts. From an evolutionary standpoint, it is most likely that early Homo sapiens, and possibly his predecessors, struck upon useful techiniques for hunting that eventually evolved into defensive and offensive methods of fighting amongst themselves. The introduction of objects as tools probably led to the development of early weaponry.

Historically, the first codified system of martial arts is usually attributed to H'uang Ti (sp), of China. The Yellow Emporer, as he was known, is said to have chronicled and organized the various practices that were characteristic of Mongolian wrestling, and that today we know as San Sou.


Goals of studying a martial art

Although generally martial arts originated to serve the goal of teaching practitioners to fight well, a number of martial arts have moved away from this as a primary goal, due perhaps in part to the relative safety of the modern world, the lower chance for the use of fighting skills, and as a result the need to continue raising interest and reasons to study the art. In particular, such a re-orientation of goals is common in martial arts with a focus on unarmed fighting skills and some hand-held weapons, which are arguably less applicable in a combat sense in the modern world. Arguably the most common martial art is that of combat shooting, which is practiced by every major national army in the world.

Alternative goals, benefits, and reasons for studying martial arts are increasing fitness, preparing for and competing in a sport, self-improvement or cultivation, mental discipline, character development, spiritual development, cultural interaction, and social interaction.

There is much debate in the martial arts community over what the "true goal" of martial arts is or should be or if there is even such a thing.

Region

The region of origin of a martial art often relates to the development of the art. Some arts that are popularly practiced today are:

  • Asia
    • China - all forms of kung fu/wushu
    • Mongolia - Mongolian wrestling
    • Japan - judo, jujutsu, aikido, karate, kendo
    • Korea - tae kwon do
    • The Philippines - escrima/kali/arnis
    • Thailand - Muay Thai
    • Indonesia/Malaysia - silat
  • Africa
  • Europe - wrestling, catch wrestling, fencing
  • The Americas
  • North America
    • USA -
  • South America
    • Brazil - capoeira, Brazilian jiu-jitsu

Sport vs. Non-sport

Some martial arts are also practiced as sports, generally combat sports but not always. Some martial arts are not practiced as sports, and some even look down on those that are practiced as sports.

Some martial arts look down on "sports arts" as being theoretically less useful in an unregulated fight and against the purpose of martial arts as well as potentially harmful to the spiritual or mental development of a martial artist, although this view is not nearly unanimous and is strongly debated by many such "sport art" practitioners, with some "sport art" practitioners going so far as to argue that the methods of training and competing for sport arts make such arts more effective in unregulated combat than many non-sport arts, and that the experience of competing in a sport makes for positive mental development.

Martial arts in combat==

On the battlefield

Personal self-defense

Combat sports

Methods of training

Training methodologies are often under hot debate, as there is a wide variety of views, many of which are explicitly incompatible with each other, on the most effective methods of training. This is further complicated by the fact that many martial arts have different goals, meaning that the training methods of two arts are often not easily compared because the end results of this training aren't towards the same purpose.

Sparring

Sparring generally refers to "free fighting", typically between two sparring partners, where both partners are allowed to use a variety of techniques at their own discretion and not restricted to using a certain order of techniques, as in a drill, usually with rules in place to protect the partners and often with extra protective equipment beyond that used in a competition or fight. In the basic and common type of sparring, partners are restricted by the same rules of the competition or fight being prepared for, with the only difference between competition and sparring being a decreased intensity in sparring.

There is a variety of sparring rules, especially for striking, as demonstrated in the concepts of contact levels in sparring, as well as "one-step" and "step sparring".

The dangers of sparring inherent to striking do not largely carry over in grappling-focused arts, so grappling arts that have sparring tend to feature this type of high-intensity sparring heavily. Grappling sparring can often be carried out with a great deal of intensity at a relatively low risk of injury.

Sparring tends to be featured heavily in martial arts that are also combat sports.

In arts that use sparring, sparring is used as a way to allow practitioners to apply techniques and skills in a safe but relatively uncontrolled setting, in order to prepare them for the chaotic nature of a real fight and to help them learn to apply the skills they have learned in this setting.

Forms and kata

There are many definitions and kinds of forms and kata, but a commonly used definition is "a prearranged set of movements designed to be used to practice techniques used in a fight." Most forms are practiced by one person alone, although some forms require the use of two people, as in judo kata.

Forms tend to be featured heavily in traditional Asian martial arts, like some forms of karate and kung fu. Forms are generally de-emphasized or non-existent in martial arts that are also combat sports, like Muay Thai and wrestling.

Drills

There are many different kinds of drills. A drill may be generally defined as any repeated motions used as practice, although the manner in which these motions are repeated and the situations in which these drills are performed vary. Drills can be categorized broadly as focused on skill-building and fitness-building, although there is almost always some aspect of both in any given drill. The actual drills themselves tend to vary greatly from art to art, often changing with the goal of the art as well as the ranges and scopes being trained for.

Skill-building drills generally stress repetition of motions or techniques used in an art in order to better these techniques and to ingrain them in muscle memory. One example of skill-building drills are the use of uchi-komis and nage-komis in judo in order to practice throws.

Fitness-building drills generally use repeated actions to build up strength, endurance, or other physical attributes rather than specific skills. One example of this is hitting a speed bag in boxing in order to develop hand-eye coordination.

Competition

While competitions are often viewed as the application of training, some martial arts see competitions as another level of training.

For example, martial arts that are also combat sports typically have a large percentage of training spent on sparring that duplicates the rules of a competition. However, sparring is different than a competition because of a difference in intensity, as sparring partners are focused on learning safely rather than "winning". In a competition, the competitors are focused on winning, often with little regard for the safety of the opponent beyond that required by the rules, so the efforts are intense and performed with full effort. This is sometimes seen as good preparation for an unregulated fight, as competitors learn the "feel" of fighting an opponent resisting at full force, as well as what adjustments are required to apply techniques to the opponent.

Other competitions, such as those for performance of kata or tile-breaking, are sometimes seen as an opportunity to test one's mental and physical abilities under pressure and to develop oneself.

Rank testing

Martial arts references in culture

Martial arts have often been mentioned in literature, paintings, and other cultural creations, and have historically played parts in national and international struggles. Some cultural creations have heavily featured martial arts and martial artists. Many societies, after gaining control over other societies, banned the practice of martial arts in attempts to prevent rebellions and uprising by trained combatants.

Some ancient Greek pottery has depictions of men wrestling and fighting each other during war and for sport, as well as engaging in martial arts sports like javelin throwing and shot putting.

Japan, during WWII, encouraged a somewhat-adapted version of samurai culture in order to bring its society to a desired fighting and sacrificial mentality.

Books like The Art of War and The Book of Five Rings became popular as people in the 50s-80s believed concepts put forth in these books to be analogous to business practices and thus valuable tactical and strategical guides.

Martial arts films are a popular subgenre of action and adventure films. Some of the earliest examples of this are the samurai films of post-WWII Japan.

Combat sports and other martial-arts-based sports are popular entertainment for live audiences and TV viewers, although combat sports, especially striking-based ones, are sometimes seen as brutal and savage. Professional boxing is very popular but perhaps currently in a decline. Mixed martial arts has one of the fastest-growing audiences of all sports.


See also

Footnotes

1 Karate, a Japanese combat form that is one of the most ubiquitous in the world gets its name from the combination of two words, kara. meaning empty, and te, meaning hand.