Yemen: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Text replacement - "Human Rights Watch" to "Human Rights Watch")
(→‎Government: adding stuff from "Republic of Yemen", which will be deleted)
Line 78: Line 78:
  | url = http://www.slate.com/id/2240481/}}</ref>
  | url = http://www.slate.com/id/2240481/}}</ref>
==Government==
==Government==
While Yemen has formal governance mechanisms, the power of tribal leadership cannot be understated. Al-Qaeda was reported to be focusing on building tribal alliances in the country. <ref name=Lowy2009-11>{{citation
| title = Al-Qa'ida, tribes and instability in Yemen
| author = [[Sarah Phillips]], [[Rodger Shanahan]]
| date = November 2009
| publisher = [[Lowy Institute for International Policy]]
|url = http://www.lowyinstitute.org/Publication.asp?pid=1192}}</ref>
The formal government of [[Yemen]] is the '''Republic of Yemen''', formed, in 1990, from [[North Yemen]] (a part of the Ottoman Empire until 1918), and [[South Yemen]] (a British protectorate until 1967). North Yemen had existed as the [[Mutawakkilite Kingdom of Yemen]] until 1962 and as the [[Yemen Arab Republic]] thereafter, with a capital in [[Sanaa]], and South Yemen as the [[People's Democratic Republic of Yemen]], having [[Aden]] as its capital. [[Ali Abdallah Salih]], former president of North Yemen, is the current Head of State.
While the Republic has an obvious Presidential system with legislative and judicial branches, Yemen has a unique combination of central and tribal government.
While Yemen has formal governance mechanisms, the power of tribal leadership cannot be understated. Al-Qaeda has been reported to be focusing on building tribal alliances. <ref name=Lowy2009-11>{{citation
While Yemen has formal governance mechanisms, the power of tribal leadership cannot be understated. Al-Qaeda has been reported to be focusing on building tribal alliances. <ref name=Lowy2009-11>{{citation
  | title = Al-Qa'ida, tribes and instability in Yemen
  | title = Al-Qa'ida, tribes and instability in Yemen
Line 94: Line 104:
  | date = December 2009
  | date = December 2009
  | publisher = Human Rights Watch}}</ref>, although the political dynamics of Yemen are far more complex than the binary distinction between North and South.
  | publisher = Human Rights Watch}}</ref>, although the political dynamics of Yemen are far more complex than the binary distinction between North and South.
===Southern secession movement===
A secessionist movement in South Yemen, headquartered in [[Aden]], asks the question, according to the ''Christian Science Monitor'', posed by a member of the minority Yemeni Socialist Party, "Eighty percent of Yemen’s oil comes from the south but where does the money go? It goes to Sanaa. The people of the south have not benefited from any of this wealth and now it is running out." Also unnamed, a Northern government member says “The south has all the resources and only one third of the population. We cannot allow them to secede,” said a member of the opposition party Islah in the capital, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he is not authorized to speak for the party. “Northerners will fight to keep Yemen together. They know it is a matter of survival.”<ref name=CSM2009-12-15>{{citation
| url =  http://www.csmonitor.com/layout/set/print/content/view/print/268998
|title = Why southern Yemen is pushing for secession: With bleak housing blocks and rusty wrecks for taxis, south Yemen residents pushing for secession say they've been sidelined by the government.
| author Michael Horton | journal = Christian Science Monitor
| date = 15 December 2009}}</ref>
===Al-Qaeda===
[[Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula]] (AQAP) has attacked targets in the country as well as operating transnationally; a suicide bombing against Korean tourists in March 2009 was one indication of domestic security problems. <ref name=Reuters2009-03-16>{{citation
| title = Qaeda suicide bomber behind Yemen tourist attack
| journal = Reuters
| date = 16 March 2009
| url = http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE52F3XM20090316}}</ref>  The group is a merger between Saudi and Yemenite groups. Its actions had been largely contained to the Arabian Peninsula, but it appears responsible for the [[Northwest Airlines Flight 253|attempted suicide bombing of a U.S. aircraft on 25 December 2009]].<ref name=StarCA2010-01-02>{{citation
| url = http://www.thestar.com/printarticle/744948
| title = Yemen: Terror threat? U.S. ally? Nearly failed state?
| date = 2 January 2010
| author = Michelle Shephard
| journal = The Star (Canada)}}</ref>
This is a newer Al-Qaeda "affiliate" than the others, and seems to have learned from their missteps. As opposed, in particular, to operations in Afghanistan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia and Sudan, the group is largely "home-grown" and cooperates much more effectively with existing tribal structures. "They've worked hard to put deep, and what they hope are lasting, roots that will make it very difficult for them to be rooted out of Yemen," says [[Gregory Johnsen]], a Yemen expert at [[Princeton University]]. "They've done a good job of looking at the mistakes that other versions of Al-Qaeda have made elsewhere."
"As long as Qaeda respects the tribes, some tribes will welcome them," says Sheikh Abdulqawi Sherif, the head of the pro-government [[Bani Dhabian]] tribe, whose territory borders the al-Qaeda strongholds of [[Mareb Province]] and [[Shebwa Province]].
Gen. Yahya Saleh, nephew of Yemen's president and the head of one of the country's counterterrorism forces agreed there were alliances, but "the tribes in Yemen are practical. They know there will be a heavy price to pay for harboring Al-Qaeda, and more and more, [the tribes] will not be willing to pay that price."<ref name=WSJ2010-01-22>{{citation
| date = 22 January 2010
| url = http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704320104575015493304519542.html?mod=WSJ_World_LeadStory#printMode
| journal = Wall Street Journal
| title = Al-Qaeda's Deep Tribal Ties Make Yemen a Terror Hub
| author = Charles Levinson and Margaret Coker
}}</ref>
====Role vs. Republic of Yemen====
Its leader appears to be Nasser al-Wahishi‎, who, among others, has been mentioned as a successor to Osama bin Laden in the overall al-Qaeda movement.
Yemen's President has offered dialogue with AQAP members, if they "...lay down their arms, renounce terrorism and return to wisdom, we are prepared to deal with them...They are a threat not only to Yemen but also to international peace and security.” <ref name=TimesUK2009-01-11>{{citation
| journal = Times (UK)
| date = 11 January 2009
| title = Yemen offers to strike a deal with al-Qaeda fighters
| url = http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/middle_east/article6982853.ece
| author = James Hyder}}</ref>
According to  Ali Hasan al-Ahmadi, the governor of the southern Shabwa Province, said: “There are dozens of Saudi and Egyptian al-Qaeda militants who came. This is in addition to Yemenis who came from Mareb and Abyan Province and a number of militants from Shabwa itself.”  The Times said that intelligence agencies may have been overly focused on Abdul Majid al-Zindani, who is now seen as an older and less influential figure, and had only recently woken up to the danger of the energetic younger Anwar al-Awlaki.
Christopher Bouckek, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said that AQAP is relatively uninvolved in the popular revolt in Yemen. Barbara Bodine said that AQAP will have more freedom to operate, but both Bodine and Bouckek agreed that Yemen's economy is the major issue driving unrest. <ref>{{citation
| title = Upheaval, Uncertainty in Yemen as Saleh Weighs Exit
| author = Christopher Boucek, Barbara Bodine
| journal =  PBS Newshour | date = 25 April 2011
| url = http://www.carnegie-mec.org/publications/?fa=43722
}}</ref>
==International relations==
There will be a 27 January 2010 meeting in [[London, United Kingdom]], called by [[Gordon Brown]], about  radicalization and the al-Qaeda threat in Yemen. [[Prime Minister of Yemen]] [[Ali Mujawar]] will represent Yemen in the gathering that will bring together representatives from governments of 21 countries including the [[G8]] nations, the [[Gulf Cooperation Council]], [[Egypt]], [[Jordan]] and [[Turkey]], as well as the [[European Union]], [[United Nations]], [[World Bank]]  and [[International Monetary Fund]], designed to support Yemen, while pushing for economic development and reform.<ref>{{citation
| url = http://www.reuters.com/assets/print?aid=USTRE60Q0A520100127
|  journal = Reuters | date = 26 January 2010
| title = London talks aim to bolster Yemen's Al-Qaeda fight}}</ref> Yemen has stated limits on its sovereignty, but is open to assistance that is compatible with its domestic politics.<ref>{{citation
| journal = Middle East News
| title = Yemen will not allow foreign troops on its soil: official source
| date = 21 January 2010
| url = http://www.monstersandcritics.com/news/middleeast/news/article_1527174.php/Yemen-will-not-allow-foreign-troops-on-its-soil-official-source}}</ref>


==References==
==References==
{{reflist|2}}
{{reflist|2}}

Revision as of 05:43, 3 September 2024

This article is a stub and thus not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.
(PD) Image: CIA World Factbook
Location of Yemen

Yemen is a country in the Middle East, formed, in 1990, from North Yemen (a part of the Ottoman Empire until 1918), and South Yemen (a British protectorate until 1967). North Yemen had existed as the Mutawakkilite Kingdom of Yemen until 1962 and as the Yemen Arab Republic thereafter, with a capital in Sanaa, and South Yemen as the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen, having Aden as its capital. Ali Abdallah Salih, former president of North Yemen, is the current Head of State.

The country has a shoreline along the Red Sea and the island of Soqotra, and shares borders with Saudi Arabia and Oman.

See also: Republic of Yemen

People

Yemenis, as opposed to other peoples of the Arabian Peninsula, do not have a nomadic tradition, but have long been settled in villages and towns.

Ethnicity and tribalism

They are primarily Arab, although there are African elements on the coast. Arabic is the official language, although English is increasingly understood in major cities. In the Mahra area (the extreme east), several non-Arabic languages are spoken. Tribes, therefore, have territories,[1] producing a very different political dynamic than, for example, when the House of Saud became a leader of the nomadic Bedouin. Yemen has a unique balance of formal and tribal governance.[2]

(PD) Image: http://ourworldflags.com
National Flag of Yemen

Religion

When the former states of north and south Yemen were established, most resident minority groups departed. Most are Muslim, divided into:

  • The majority Shafa'i school of Sunni Muslims, found in the south and southeast
  • Shi'a Zaidi sect, found in the north and northwest. The Houthi resistance group says it is fighting to stop marginalization of the Zaidi.[3]

Former U.S. Ambassador to Yemen Edmund Hull writes that most sources overestimate Sunni-Shiite tension. "both the Houthis and President Saleh are followers of the Zaidi sect of Shiite Islam. Generally, there is no clear divide between Sunnis and Shiites in Yemen, although the Shiites tend to live in the north and northwest while the Sunnis, mostly members of the moderate Shafii school, predominate in the south and southeast. In any case, one’s sect matters far less in Yemen than in countries like Lebanon or Iraq, and it’s not unknown for Yemenis to convert from Sunni to Shiite as a matter of convenience."[4]

National history

Unification took place for a number of reasons. In President Salih's 1990 speech, three factors went into a broad desire for national identity:

  • "the return to a lost “golden age”
  • the removal of the effects of monarchy and imperialism
  • the desire for pan-Arab unity, with Yemeni unity as a preliminary step."[5]

Economics

Among the poorest countries of the Arab world, it has had average annual growth in the range of 3-4% from 2000 through 2007. Its economic fortunes depend mostly on declining oil resources, but the country is trying to diversify its earnings. Preliminary estimates for 2008 a GDP growth rate of 4.4 percent as compared to 4.2 percent in the previous year. "Higher oil revenues and some progress in tax collections also helped to reduce the fiscal deficit to 4.3 percent of GDP and the current account deficit to around 2 percent of GDP. Given that oil prices were very high during the first nine months of the year, the overall economic performance in 2008 is disappointing and underscores the difficult challenges faced by Yemen."[6]

In 2006 Yemen began an economic reform program designed to bolster non-oil sectors of the economy and foreign investment. As a result of the program, international donors pledged about $5 billion for development projects. In November 2006, a World Bank-sponsored international donors conference held in London raised $4.7 billion for Yemen's development; the funds are to be disbursed between 2007 and 2010.

Officials from the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries held a donors' conference in Saudi Arabia in June 2009. Approximately USD $3.5 billion was pledged to projects in 2007 through 2010. of which about nearly 90 percent has been made available to 50 development projects. [7]

Agriculture

Diverting resources from food crops, and indeed necessitating the import of food, is the widespread propagation of the stimulant qat.[8]

Government

While Yemen has formal governance mechanisms, the power of tribal leadership cannot be understated. Al-Qaeda was reported to be focusing on building tribal alliances in the country. [9]

The formal government of Yemen is the Republic of Yemen, formed, in 1990, from North Yemen (a part of the Ottoman Empire until 1918), and South Yemen (a British protectorate until 1967). North Yemen had existed as the Mutawakkilite Kingdom of Yemen until 1962 and as the Yemen Arab Republic thereafter, with a capital in Sanaa, and South Yemen as the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen, having Aden as its capital. Ali Abdallah Salih, former president of North Yemen, is the current Head of State.

While the Republic has an obvious Presidential system with legislative and judicial branches, Yemen has a unique combination of central and tribal government. While Yemen has formal governance mechanisms, the power of tribal leadership cannot be understated. Al-Qaeda has been reported to be focusing on building tribal alliances. [9]

Government corruption is a severe problem. [10] Human Rights Watch reported, in December 2009, that the government was dominated by northerners, who suppressed southern interests, [11], although the political dynamics of Yemen are far more complex than the binary distinction between North and South.

Southern secession movement

A secessionist movement in South Yemen, headquartered in Aden, asks the question, according to the Christian Science Monitor, posed by a member of the minority Yemeni Socialist Party, "Eighty percent of Yemen’s oil comes from the south but where does the money go? It goes to Sanaa. The people of the south have not benefited from any of this wealth and now it is running out." Also unnamed, a Northern government member says “The south has all the resources and only one third of the population. We cannot allow them to secede,” said a member of the opposition party Islah in the capital, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he is not authorized to speak for the party. “Northerners will fight to keep Yemen together. They know it is a matter of survival.”[12]

Al-Qaeda

Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) has attacked targets in the country as well as operating transnationally; a suicide bombing against Korean tourists in March 2009 was one indication of domestic security problems. [13] The group is a merger between Saudi and Yemenite groups. Its actions had been largely contained to the Arabian Peninsula, but it appears responsible for the attempted suicide bombing of a U.S. aircraft on 25 December 2009.[14]

This is a newer Al-Qaeda "affiliate" than the others, and seems to have learned from their missteps. As opposed, in particular, to operations in Afghanistan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia and Sudan, the group is largely "home-grown" and cooperates much more effectively with existing tribal structures. "They've worked hard to put deep, and what they hope are lasting, roots that will make it very difficult for them to be rooted out of Yemen," says Gregory Johnsen, a Yemen expert at Princeton University. "They've done a good job of looking at the mistakes that other versions of Al-Qaeda have made elsewhere."

"As long as Qaeda respects the tribes, some tribes will welcome them," says Sheikh Abdulqawi Sherif, the head of the pro-government Bani Dhabian tribe, whose territory borders the al-Qaeda strongholds of Mareb Province and Shebwa Province. Gen. Yahya Saleh, nephew of Yemen's president and the head of one of the country's counterterrorism forces agreed there were alliances, but "the tribes in Yemen are practical. They know there will be a heavy price to pay for harboring Al-Qaeda, and more and more, [the tribes] will not be willing to pay that price."[15]

Role vs. Republic of Yemen

Its leader appears to be Nasser al-Wahishi‎, who, among others, has been mentioned as a successor to Osama bin Laden in the overall al-Qaeda movement.

Yemen's President has offered dialogue with AQAP members, if they "...lay down their arms, renounce terrorism and return to wisdom, we are prepared to deal with them...They are a threat not only to Yemen but also to international peace and security.” [16]

According to Ali Hasan al-Ahmadi, the governor of the southern Shabwa Province, said: “There are dozens of Saudi and Egyptian al-Qaeda militants who came. This is in addition to Yemenis who came from Mareb and Abyan Province and a number of militants from Shabwa itself.” The Times said that intelligence agencies may have been overly focused on Abdul Majid al-Zindani, who is now seen as an older and less influential figure, and had only recently woken up to the danger of the energetic younger Anwar al-Awlaki.

Christopher Bouckek, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said that AQAP is relatively uninvolved in the popular revolt in Yemen. Barbara Bodine said that AQAP will have more freedom to operate, but both Bodine and Bouckek agreed that Yemen's economy is the major issue driving unrest. [17]

International relations

There will be a 27 January 2010 meeting in London, United Kingdom, called by Gordon Brown, about radicalization and the al-Qaeda threat in Yemen. Prime Minister of Yemen Ali Mujawar will represent Yemen in the gathering that will bring together representatives from governments of 21 countries including the G8 nations, the Gulf Cooperation Council, Egypt, Jordan and Turkey, as well as the European Union, United Nations, World Bank and International Monetary Fund, designed to support Yemen, while pushing for economic development and reform.[18] Yemen has stated limits on its sovereignty, but is open to assistance that is compatible with its domestic politics.[19]

References

  1. Elham M. Manea (10-11 October 1996.), Yemen, the tribe and the state, International Colloquium on Islam and Social Change, University of Lausanne
  2. Megan Stack (27 May 2007), "21st century Yemenis embrace the ancient power of the tribes: Mideast's potent force endures alongside the Internet and cellphone.", Los Angeles Times
  3. Kristen Chick (11 November 2009), "Yemen's Houthi rebels get Iran assurance, ask Saudis to stop strikes", Christian Science Monitor
  4. Edmund Hull (12 January 2010), "Op-Ed Contributor: Al-Qaeda’s Shadowland", New York Times
  5. Brian Whitaker (2009), 1. One nation, two Yemens, The Birth of Modern Yemen
  6. Yemen Economic Update, World Bank, Spring 2009
  7. GCC Countries support Yemen unity, security and development, Global Arab Network, 14 June 2009
  8. Brian Palmer (4 January 2010), "Why Is Yemen So Poor? Conflict, corruption, and qat", Slate
  9. 9.0 9.1 Sarah Phillips, Rodger Shanahan (November 2009), Al-Qa'ida, tribes and instability in Yemen, Lowy Institute for International Policy
  10. Yemen Corruption Assessment, U.S. Agency for International Development, 25 September 2006
  11. In the Name of Unity: The Yemeni Government’s Brutal Response to Southern Movement Protests, Human Rights Watch, December 2009
  12. "Why southern Yemen is pushing for secession: With bleak housing blocks and rusty wrecks for taxis, south Yemen residents pushing for secession say they've been sidelined by the government.", Christian Science Monitor, 15 December 2009
  13. "Qaeda suicide bomber behind Yemen tourist attack", Reuters, 16 March 2009
  14. Michelle Shephard (2 January 2010), "Yemen: Terror threat? U.S. ally? Nearly failed state?", The Star (Canada)
  15. Charles Levinson and Margaret Coker (22 January 2010), "Al-Qaeda's Deep Tribal Ties Make Yemen a Terror Hub", Wall Street Journal
  16. James Hyder (11 January 2009), "Yemen offers to strike a deal with al-Qaeda fighters", Times (UK)
  17. Christopher Boucek, Barbara Bodine (25 April 2011), "Upheaval, Uncertainty in Yemen as Saleh Weighs Exit", PBS Newshour
  18. "London talks aim to bolster Yemen's Al-Qaeda fight", Reuters, 26 January 2010
  19. "Yemen will not allow foreign troops on its soil: official source", Middle East News, 21 January 2010