CZ:Proposals/Approval system for CZ: pages
This proposal has not yet been assigned to any decisionmaking group or decisionmaker(s).
The Proposals Manager will do so soon if and when the proposal or issue is "well formed" (including having a driver).
For now, the proposal record can be found in the new proposals queue.
Complete explanation
I think we just extend the Approval/Draft system to all CZ pages. They become approved once approved by executive committee members, and then a draft is open to revise. I think an approved version should remain editable for minor things without re-approval. But there will be two versions, a formally approved version, and an evolving draft alternative.
Proposed Approval process for CZ: pages.
A member of the executive committee places a "ToApprove" template on the article's talk (discussion) page. That template will be marked with a date, usually several days to a week from the date that it is placed - but at least 24 hours.
If the approval template remains there, approval will occur on that date. Meanwhile, discussion and edits continue. Edits at this stage should be made only by executive committee members, involved authors and relevcant parties (e.g. constables). Other members of Citizendium should make recommendations and criticisms on the talk page.
If another member of the executive committee finds that the page is so objectionable that approval should not be granted, then the template is removed by this member, who explains why on the talk page.
If the nominator notes that the discussion on the talk page that has occurred since the nomination for approval brings up important objections, then he or she may delay the date for approval to allow for work to continue. The nominator may also change the version nominated for approval on the "to approve" template to an updated draft.
Unless the template is removed, on the designated date, a sysop then freezes the approved version of the article under an Approved template. At that freeze, a draft form of the article is generated. This draft is open to edits as are all unapproved articles on the wiki.
After approval, copyediting and minor changes may be performed by any member of the executive committee with the help of the approvals editor. This may occur at any time.
Who may approve:
For any CZ page, only members of the executive committee may approve.
Reasoning
Below is copied the discussion from an earlier, discarded proposal (See [[CZ:Proposals > CZ Community pages should be revised for simplicity]]), that led to the present proposal.
That proposal was justified thus: "....Part of what is keeping our "elitism shield" up is that many (if not all) of the community pages are overly complex. A campaign to heavily review and edit the pages will give us leaner, easy-to-comprehend documentation and improve our external appearance."
Implementation
As far as I can see this just needs Executive Committee endorsement.
Discussion
See [[CZ:Proposals > CZ Community pages should be revised for simplicity]]
| Proposals System Navigation (advanced users only) | |
|
Proposal lists (some planned pages are still blank):
|