Singapore Polytechnic stabbing
| Tan Chin Liong | |
|---|---|
| Other names | 陈振隆 |
| |
| Born | 1945 Malaysia |
| Died | 22 November 1990 (aged 45) Singapore Polytechnic, Dover Road, Singapore |
| Occupation | Lecturer of the Electronics and Communication Engineering department |
On 22 November 1990, 20-year-old National Serviceman Lee Teck Sang (李德生 Lǐ Déshēng), who deserted from his army and hid himself at the campus of Singapore Polytechnic (where Lee was an alumnus of the institution) for 17 days, used a knife to murder a 45-year-old lecturer during a robbery. The victim, Tan Chin Liong (陈振隆 Chén Zhènlóng), died as a result of being stabbed thrice. Although Lee claimed that he only meant to rob and the stabbing was meant to incapacitate Tan, the High Court rejected Lee's defence and found Lee guilty of murdering Tan, and sentenced him to death. Lee's appeal was dismissed and he was hanged on 29 July 1994.
Murder
On the morning of 22 November 1990, at 7.15am, a lecturer discovered one of his senior colleagues lying dead on the seventh floor corridor outside his office at the Dover Road campus of Singapore Polytechnic.[1]
The victim was identified as 45-year-old Tan Chin Liong, a lecturer from the Electronics and Communication Engineering department of the polytechnic. He sustained a total of three stab wounds, with one on his abdomen and two on his chest.[2] Preliminary investigations by the Singapore Police Force also determined that the possible motive behind Tan's death was robbery and Tan was possibly attacked at around 5am to 7am, at most a couple of hours before the body was discovered. The police also noticed a blood trail coming from the victim's body, and followed the bloodstains to the female toilet on the sixth floor. Inside, they arrested a man who was hiding inside one of the cubicles. The young bespectacled man was wearing only a pair of white shorts, and two bags were seized from the toilet; one of them contained a bloodstained shirt and a knife. The suspect was also identified as a former student of the polytechnic, having graduated early in 1990, and he was also a deserter of National Service.[3][4][5]
The brutal killing of Tan brought shock to his brother and many people present at the campus, and it disrupted the lessons of many students at the polytechnic.[6][7] Reportedly, they showed outrage at the suspect's brutal conduct and sadness for Tan, who was known to be a good teacher and kind-hearted person. The school staff of the polytechnic also stated that they would introduce the necessary measures to tighten the security on the campus to prevent similar incidents from happening.[8]
The bespectacled suspect, 20-year-old Lee Teck Sang, was charged with murder on 23 November 1990, a day after his arrest.[9][10][11]
Lee's case was later transferred to the High Court in June 1991, with a trial pending to be scheduled to take place on a later date.[12][13][14]
Background
Tan Chin Liong was a Malaysian who came from Johor Bahru. He was born in a family of ten brothers and sisters. He finished his secondary school education in Malaysia before furthering his studies at England, obtaining a master's degree in engineering. Tan worked at Singapore Polytechnic as a lecturer for more than ten years before his murder. According to his students, Tan was a well-mannered, approachable and unassuming person who treated his students well and helped them in their school work. Many of his pupils were reportedly shocked and saddened to hear about his death.[15][16][17] Tan was also single and did not have a girlfriend due to him spending most of his time on research and work, and he was extremely thrifty.[18][19][20]
As for the suspect Lee Teck Sang, who was born in Singapore in 1970, he used to study at Qi Hua Primary School and also completed his secondary school education at Yuan Ching Secondary, where he graduated with a GCE O-level certificate. Lee enrolled in Singapore Polytechnic, where he studied before he graduated with a diploma on electronics and communication in early 1990, a few months before he allegedly killed Tan. Lee, who lived in Boon Lay, was the seventh child out of eight children, and he had two older brothers, four older sisters and one younger brother. His father died as of 1994 and his mother (aged 50 in 1990) worked as a cleaner. Lee was said to have a good student-teacher relationship with Tan, who often showed concern for his welfare and school work.[21]
Trial of Lee Teck Sang
Two years after Tan Chin Liong was murdered, his killer Lee Teck Sang was officially brought to trial at the High Court on 5 October 1992. Lee was represented by Ram Goswami, and the prosecution led by Han Cher Kwang, and the trial was presided by veteran judge T S Sinnathuray, who was best known for sentencing Adrian Lim and his two accomplices to the gallows for the ritual killings of two children at Toa Payoh.
Several prosecution witnesses came to court to give evidence. One of them, Corporal Azman Abdul Aziz of the Singapore Police Force, testified that he was the first to discover the blood trail that started from the location of Tan's dead body and led to the toilet where they found Lee, who surrendered to the officers upon their arrival.[22] Another was Professor Chao Tzee Cheng, a senior forensic pathologist who conducted the autopsy on the victim. Professor Chao testified that out of the three stab wounds, one of them was inflicted on the chest and had penetrated the heart, and this injury resulted into an excessive loss of blood, which was sufficient to cause the death of Tan within minutes.[23][24]
The court was also told that Lee, who was then serving his National Service, was scheduled to go to Pulau Tekong in early November 1990 to start his military training, and Lee, who was unable to face the stress of military training, decided to desert from his National Service, and he fled to Singapore Polytechnic, where he hid for the next 17 days. Lee spent the daytime reading books in the campus library while spent his nights inside a classroom during the 17 days he spent at the campus. Eventually, Lee ran out of money, and he could not ask his mother or siblings for help since they were notified of his desertion and attempted to get information from him about his whereabouts each time he contacted his family. Therefore, Lee decided to commit robbery. He also targeted the victim Tan Chin Liong since he observed Tan for some time and noticed the lecturer often came very early in the morning everyday for work.[25]
Lee's account further revealed that after he formulated the plan to rob Tan, he went to a nearby store to procure a knife, and waited for Tan on that morning of 22 November 1990. From this point on, according to Lee's version of what happened, he spotted Tan and proceeded to attack the lecturer, stabbing him in the stomach first in order to incapacitate the man so as to rob Tan, but Tan put up a fierce physical resistance and tried to disarm Lee. Lee said that during the scuffle, the knife had somehow penetrated Tan's chest without his knowledge, and he stated that the death of 45-year-old Tan Chin Liong was not within his calculations, and he only intend to rob the victim and stab him only once in the stomach to incapacitate him. From the robbery, Lee managed to steal SGD$48 in cash from the fallen victim before he fled to the toilet where he was eventually caught.[26]
In rebuttal, the prosecution argued that Lee had intentionally stabbed Tan in the heart instead of accidentally, and he had committed murder by intentionally inflicting a fatal injury upon Tan, with pursuant to Section 300(c) of the Penal Code. They pointed out that Lee's use of a knife was for the purpose of committing armed robbery and also for the intention to cause hurt if necessary. The stabbing of Tan was also done in furtherance of Lee's original intent to rob Tan and one of the knife wounds to the chest was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. As such, the prosecution argued that the elements of proving a murder charge had been satisfied and there were sufficient grounds to warrant a guilty verdict of murder in Lee's case.[27][28]
On 7 October 1992, merely two days after Lee stood trial, Justice Sinnathuray delivered his judgement. In his verdict, Justice Sinnathuray found that based on the evidence, Lee had intentionally caused the three knife wounds on Tan, and one of these wounds, which was intentionally directed at the chest and cut through the heart, was fatal and resulted in the death of the victim by massive blood loss from the wound, and the decision by Lee to arm himself with a knife also corroborated the fact that he had the intention to use the weapon to cause harm if necessary.[29]
On behalf of these findings, Justice Sinnathuray found 22-year-old Lee Teck Sang guilty of murder, and sentenced him to death. Under Section 302 of the Penal Code, the death penalty was mandatory for offenders guilty of murder, and judges had no discretion to sentence the murder offenders to any other punishment aside from death.[30]
Appeal
On 17 January 1994, during his second year on death row, Lee Teck Sang's appeal against his conviction and sentence was rejected by the Court of Appeal.
In their verdict, the three judges - two Judges of Appeal M Karthigesu and L P Thean, and Chief Justice Yong Pung How - stated that based on the findings of the trial judge and evidence, it was abundantly clear that Lee had intended to stab the victim Tan Chin Liong on the chest, such that the injury was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, which satisfied the basic elements of a murder charge on the grounds of intentionally causing a fatal injury to the victim. Therefore, the three appellate judges upheld Lee's death sentence and murder conviction, and accordingly dismissed his appeal.[31][32]
Execution
On 29 July 1994, six months after losing his appeal, 24-year-old Lee Teck Sang was hanged in Changi Prison at dawn. Lee did not petition for presidential clemency during the final months before he was put to death.[33][34]
On the same date of Lee's execution, four other inmates were also executed at the same prison: Ibrahim Masod who kidnapped and killed a goldsmith, Goh Hong Choon who strangled a ten-year-old schoolgirl during a robbery, and two people convicted of drug trafficking in two separate cases.[35][36][37]
The Singapore Polytechnic murder case was known to be one of the rare few cases of murders happening in the school compounds of certain educational institutions in Singapore.[38]
See also
Footnotes
- ↑ 年轻讲师目睹同事卧尸血泊, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 死者被刺多刀, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ Poly lecturer killed on campus, 23 November 1990.
- ↑ 70公尺长血迹破案, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 厕所内找到血衣凶器, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 弟弟惊闻兄被害, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 警方封锁现场学生不能上课, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 命案发生后学院加强保安, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ Polytechnic graduate charged with murder, 24 November 1990.
- ↑ 嫌凶冷漠上庭, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 工院讲师遇害案 嫌凶被控谋杀, 24 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ Grad to he tried for murder, 15 June 1991.
- ↑ 青年涉嫌 刺杀讲师, 14 June 1991. (in zh)
- ↑ 工院生谋杀讲师罪名成立, 15 June 1991. (in zh)
- ↑ S'pore Poly steps up security on campus after lecturer's murder, 24 November 1990.
- ↑ 好老师遇害工院学生震惊, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 死者"乐于助人"甚受学生爱戴, 22 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 被害讲师是钻石王老五 内向又热爱研究未有女朋友, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 死者有金表会否与案有关？, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 死者积蓄颇丰人称‘小富翁’, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ 讲师·嫌凶关系密切, 23 November 1990. (in zh)
- ↑ Lecturer's murder: Blood trail led to accused in toilet', 6 October 1992.
- ↑ 讲师中三刀心脏破裂死, 5 October 1992. (in zh)
- ↑ 涉嫌谋杀新加坡工院讲师毕业生李德生开始受审, 6 October 1992. (in zh)
- ↑ 17 days in Poly hideout, 9 October 1992.
- ↑ 被告：不认识对方 死者早到学院，便成抢劫目标, 7 October 1992. (in zh)
- ↑ Poly grad: I did not intend to kill lecturer, 7 October 1992.
- ↑ 谋杀讲师罪成立工院生被判死刑, 8 October 1992. (in zh)
- ↑ Army deserter to hang for murder of poly lecturer, 8 October 1992.
- ↑ 抢劫不遂起杀心·逃兵罪名成立 谋杀讲师判处死刑, 7 October 1992. (in zh)
- ↑ 谋杀讲师判死刑 工院生上诉遭驳回, 17 January 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ 工院前毕业生谋杀讲师上诉被驳回, 18 January 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ 两毒贩三杀人犯昨上绞台, 30 July 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ 抢劫讲师 猛刺4刀, 29 July 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ Five hanged in Singapore, 30 July 1994.
- ↑ 3杀人犯2毒贩难逃法网 5名死囚 一起上绞台, 29 July 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ 尼日利亚酋长与狮城德士司机 2名毒贩今上绞刑台, 29 July 1994. (in zh)
- ↑ 过去校园谋杀案, 14 August 2003. (in zh)